BLOG-088 | Transference and Countertransference: A CPE Learner's Guide

Your first year in Clinical Pastoral Education, someone will ask you why a particular visit rattled you more than it should have. Maybe a patient reminded you of your own father. Maybe a family's anger toward the hospital left you defensive for the rest of your shift. That is the moment your supervisor is waiting for, because it is the moment CPE actually teaches something. The names for what happened are transference and countertransference, and learning to see them is one of the most practical skills a chaplain in formation can build.

What is transference in a pastoral encounter?

Transference is what a patient, family member, or care recipient brings to you that does not actually belong to you. They meet you for ten minutes, and something about your voice, your collar, or your presence stirs feelings that trace back to another relationship entirely: a parent, a clergyperson from childhood, an old authority figure. A grieving widower may lean on you the way he leaned on his brother. An angry teenager may treat you like the father who was never present. None of it is really about you. It is about who you have come to represent in that moment.

This is not a distraction from ministry. It is often the doorway into the real pastoral work. Scripture itself shows people projecting need onto God's messengers: the woman at the well meets Jesus and, before the conversation is over, is talking about her whole marital history and her people's history of worship (John 4:7-26). Jesus does not correct the drift. He follows it toward what she actually needs. Recognizing transference means noticing what a person is really asking for underneath what they are saying to you.

What is countertransference, and why does CPE care so much about it?

Countertransference runs the other direction. It is your own unresolved history rising up in response to a patient. The dying man who reminds you of your grandfather. The combative family member who triggers old wounds from your own childhood home. The patient whose suffering feels unbearable because it echoes a loss you have not fully grieved yourself.

CPE supervision exists largely to help you catch this before it steers a visit. An unnoticed countertransference can make you over-identify with a patient, avoid a room you should enter, or push comfort on someone who needed silence instead. Paul's warning to "examine yourselves" (2 Corinthians 13:5) is usually read as a spiritual discipline, and it is exactly the discipline a chaplain needs in the room: a habit of checking your own reactions before you trust them as pastoral guidance.

How do you catch it while it is happening?

You will rarely see countertransference in the moment it starts. You catch the aftershock: a visit that leaves you unusually tired, unusually irritated, or unusually attached. Build the habit of asking three questions as soon as you leave the room.

• What did I feel that seemed bigger than the situation called for? Strong reactions are data. They are rarely random.
• Who does this person remind me of, and what does that relationship carry? Name it specifically. Vague unease stays confusing; a named memory becomes workable.
• What did I want to do in that room, and why? Wanting to fix, rescue, argue, or flee are common countertransference signals. Notice the urge before you decide whether to act on it.

Bring the honest answers to supervision and to your verbatim group. This is the entire purpose of a verbatim: not to prove you handled the visit correctly, but to expose the moment where your own history and the patient's history collided, so a supervisor can help you see what you could not see alone.

What do you do about it once you see it?

Awareness is not the finish line. Once you can name a pattern, you have two jobs. First, use the insight to serve the patient better: if you recognize that a patient's hostility is aimed at "chaplains" or "the hospital" and not at you personally, you can stay present instead of getting defensive. Second, tend your own formation: if a certain kind of patient consistently pulls at an old wound, that is a signal for your own inner work, not a flaw to hide from your supervisor. CPE is designed to surface exactly this kind of material so it can be worked through in a supported setting rather than acted out unsupervised in a patient's room.

Jesus modeled the discipline of withdrawing to examine himself before ministry, not only after it (Luke 5:16). A chaplain who never pauses to ask what a hard visit stirred in them will eventually let old material run the room. A chaplain who builds the habit of self-examination turns every difficult encounter into formation instead of just survival.

The skill that makes every future visit safer

Transference and countertransference are not problems to eliminate. They are permanent features of any relationship built on care, and every experienced chaplain still encounters them. What changes with formation is not whether these dynamics appear, but how quickly you notice them and how honestly you bring them to supervision. That noticing is what CPE is actually training, underneath the paperwork and the verbatims.

Start now, in your first unit, by naming one moment this week when a visit affected you more than the facts alone explain. Bring it to your group before it has time to calcify into an unexamined pattern.

Take one step this week. Write down the next strong reaction you notice after a visit, before you talk yourself out of its significance. If you want a structured way to practice reading and processing pastoral encounters, explore Verbatim practice on LightBearer, or read our companion piece on writing your first verbatim.

Drafted with AI assistance and reviewed under CRN editorial standards.

(c) 2026 Marsh Institute for Chaplains. Chaplain Resource Network is an initiative of the Marsh Institute for Chaplains. All rights reserved.